Nuance! Kappers meer risico op kanker

…zo werd een bericht vorige week de wereld ingestuurd. Kappers zouden toch meer risico op kanker hebben als gevolg van het werken met haarverven. Een werkgroep van de WHO zou tot deze conclusie zijn gekomen. De beroemde anonieme chemici van The Beauty Brains zijn er eens in gedoken en kwamen tot de volgende geruststellende conclusie…

 

Vooropgesteld: hier lees je het voltallige rapport!

En dan nu wat The Beauty Brains erover te vertellen hebben:

'Now I'm no medical researcher, but I'm even more confused after reading this. Basically it says the panel evaluated 17 different chemicals and rated them by the following criteria:

  • Exposure data (where/how used)
  • Human carcinogenicity data (any proof it causes cancer in humans)
  • Animal carcinogenicity data (any proof it causes cancer in animals)
  • Other relevant data

The study evaluates whether or not there is sufficient data to indicate the chemical poses a risk of human or animal carcinogenicity. It also provides an overall assessment that states whether the chemical can be classified as not carcinogenic, possibly carcinogenic, or probably carcinogenic.

What does this all mean?mocha

Of the 17 chemical reviewed:

  • 10 were not classifiable as to their carcinogenicity
  • 6 where possibly carcinogenic
  • 1 was probably carcinogenic.

The one chemical that had any clear indication of human carcinogenicity was 4, 4′-Methylenebis (2-chlorobenzenamine) or MOCA for short. But based on the report, MOCA is not used in hair dyes (and in a quick web search, I couldn't find any evidence of hair dyes that used MOCA either.)

Of the six chemicals that were rated as "possibly carcinogenic" none are listed as being used in hair dyes. (One of them HC Blue 1, was banned from hair dye use in the 1980s. The rest are used in textiles, leather, or wool and one was used in manufacture of pesticides and similar compounds.) So to summarize:

  • The report says there's no evidence of cancer risk for consumers who color their hair.
  • The report says there is a risk for professional hairdressers and barbers.
  • But looking at the details in the report, I only see risks associated with chemicals that are not used in hair dyes anymore.

The Beauty Brains bottom line

I'm not trying to come across as a defender of dangerous chemicals but based on this report it doesn't seem to me that they've shown any link real between the dyes used in hair dyes and cancer.

 

Lees ook:Kanker door cosmeticagebruik?
Lees ook:Vollere lippen! Werken lip plumpers wel?
Lees ook:Bieden op een make-over van Mari van de Ven
Lees ook:Liever mooi dan slim ?
Lees ook:Wereldmarkt anti-agingproducten 115 miljard dollar in 2010

Geen reacties // Reageer

Geef een reactie

Het e-mailadres wordt niet gepubliceerd. Verplichte velden zijn gemarkeerd met *

Naam

Website

Het kan vijf minuten duren voordat nieuwe reacties zichtbaar zijn.

De volgende HTML tags en attributen zijn toegestaan: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>